He is, by my estimation, the most interesting part of either epilogue, anyway. Hussie didn't make John and Karkat et al drop the r word to say anything about them, that's just a word he himself used to use, so his characters did too. Some of my other favorites among Homestucks ten main albums and many more side-releases include Unite Synchronization, Derse Dreamers, I Dont Want to Miss A Thing, At the Price of Oblivion, and Showtime. Eventually, she goes on to write a widely read manifesto; taking the reins of a militant revolutionary group that wears goth clown makeup. It did, by the way. "Queer Eye" star Karamo Brown recently told INSIDER that he thinks the beloved film about a gay relationship, " Call Me by Your Name ," is "problematic as f---." Press J to jump to the feed. Web1. A federal prison will be our emerald city. Constantly seeking out fetishistic situations and sexualizing characters in a fantasy story as well reading straight up bullshit from in-between the lines. But how much is that purpose worth? They dont have a concept of incest and I wouldnt be surprised if they werent bothered by age Gaps either with how impersonal their mating is. Homestuck Due to fans arguing over the race of characters Hussie put in a joke in which one of the characters (jane) says "I feel so caucasion" when she's in trickster mode. Thats how obsessive preoccupation works, and its an accelerator of these forms of online cultism. The language is deeply rooted in the now, and leans into the internet vernacular with words like simp, e-girls, reply guys, and cringe. At one point, one of the protagonists moves from being a fan, to dating a member of the popular K-pop group BTS (which also happens to be one of the biggest, most influential fandoms of the moment). As for Karkat using "autistic" as an insult did he really? Apple @ Work: Why Wi-Fi 6E solves a major problem for IT That should be plenty to say on how wrong it is, with Meenah being a literal adult and this Vriska being a literal child. If you have an argument other than deformed kids (which I just said they shouldn't have), go ahead and try to change my mind. ya. Cyberduds. Cohen fucked up when making that "announcement". https://linktr.ee/moblack, Pumpkin Party in Sea Hitlers Water Apocalypse, pages that change their formatting to fit different, this first conversation between John and Terezi. Its digitally illustrated and lets you click through like you would in a narrative game. The character doesn't exist though, the author made them say it. Gross Margin. what problematic homestuck character are you? - Personality Quiz No one considered it a slur yet. When I speak of fandom Im referring to the activity which is more indicative of obsession, hyperfixation, the need for a sense of belonging to a greater movement, and starting to let that feeling shape your identity. The Homestuck Discord exists at https://discord.gg/homestuck if you want to chat with fellow fans. Its fitting. The Candy author on the other hand, represented by Calliope, cares little for if whats happening on screen is important or not. You mean I cant wear the same thing I wore when I was younger? Problem I asked Hussie if he thinks everyone should just log off. The Google docs had like 2 or 3 good points and the rest is just bullshit. However, Dirks enemy isnt necessarily Calliope, its the very fact that stories end, and, when they do, everyone and everything existing after the end fades from relevance. [Updated] DISH network looking into authentication or login This event kickstarts her own story and accelerates the development of her own personal politics. Maybe it would help if I knew what "AAVE" is, though. Hussie said he returned to the 140,000 word long draft, cut the story in half, and tried to make it feel like something legitimately worth reading to anyone who crossed the full span of 2020s madness.. I thought we were more on the page of "Hussie is terrible because of recent incidents like the released emails between the moderation team and him", Man like almost every single criticism this person presents can be explained away with one of 3 responses. And in this one Mituna himself just kind of sexually harrasses Meenah. Tavros treatment in homestuck is also disgusting, in all honesty. Vrisrezi | Shipping Wiki | Fandom N/A. Not formally, and nowhere near as dangerous as more conventional cults can be, but close enough to draw meaningful comparisons. He would commandeer a handful of characters, and I do the same. umm?" If so, then there's nothing "wrong" with that, because they had no way of knowing they are related. When I logged in every post I saw on the issue was complaining about how more people were complaining about people complaining about the Caucasian thing than there were people complaining about the Caucasian thing. Alternia, at least at first, is a dark joke about our real-world society. HOMESTUCK The easiest example of this is Dave's HELLA toxic masculinity in the early game. Webit has some stuff that aged poorly and is very typical of the comedy and internet culture at the time that it was written. Unless you believe the existence of these controversies is a matter of opinion, as I'm willing to firmly disagree with you on that matter. Where does this leave a generation that grew up online, many of whom were devout Homestuck readers? There are pages that break the style of the website, pages that change the CSS are common, and there are pages that change their formatting to fit different content. The fact that Homestuck isn't an anime makes them unpopular at anime conventions, despite things like video game and doctor who costumes being accepted in part because Given troll reproduction, it seems to some people as though the only reason they're given them in the comic is to sexualize them for a human audience. I understand the logic of HIC's quirk and presentation, but I DO think there is value in talking about the harmful stereotypes which she is made from. WebRead MS Paint Adventures. The Meat author, portrayed here by Dirk, is hyper-focused on moving the plot forward. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I can't fight that. Submit fanart, cosplay and discussions of all kinds! 36.87%. Music is so integral to the experience of Homestuck Id argue the story doesnt work without it. problem Homestuck is honestly a sprawling epic I mean, kind of. People have clamored for us to produce high quality cosplay-ready horns for years, ever since I began working at WP. I honestly don't feel qualified to say. Or perhaps the second option catches your eye. On revolution, telling stories, and logging off. I cant put them on a scale from 1 to 10 and I cant recommend anyone read them or not. The flaws of each epilogue reflect the flaws in Meat and Candy as narrative frames of mind. But theyre also very upsetting in general. There was some controversy when homestuck first came out. While the jokes are not necessarily at Terezis expenseshe is usually the one making themthere is still the problem of a definitely not-blind author writing them. I'm part of the tumblr community and several others. I didn't even know that there is a stereotype until now. But understanding that Psycholonials is chiefly an anti-cult narrative should help point to how I view the Homestuck phenomenon. Point 1: Homestuck is 'problematic' in the way that many people are beginning to dislike. Brown, who has worked with survivors of sexual assault as a therapist and social worker, believes that the movie glorifies " predatory behavior." Below, Karkat (in the gray text) mocks Tavros (in the brown text). "Babyed or harassed"? I wouldnt be the snarky, nitpicking college kid with a blog if I didnt start that snarky nitpicking on Reddit and among fans complaining about, say, how retconning [S] Game Over totally ruined the emotional impact of the story up until that point. But Hussie was ready for something new, and in his words, anti-cult.. Whereas Tavros was never given a choice, Terezi is, and she turns it down. My ask box is always open for corrections, things I may have missed, or just general discussions of my posts. Maybe you watched a lot of Naruto, so your big project is filled to the brim with edgy ninjas and impractically sized swords. For the Beta Kids, it's Jade, for the Trolls it's Vriska, and for the Alpha kids it's Dirk. The fact that they changed it is what's wrong. Every single one of those tags appears somewhere in the story, including but not limited to: unhealthy relationships, graphic depictions of violence, transphobia, rape, major character death, and (may God help us all) eggs. And then they have a kid who she abuses. WebFollowing the incident, What Pumpkin, Hussies former Homestuck production company (which he has since left), threatened to sue Sarah Z. No, I am pretty sure that's because there's a sex "scene" that they didn't want children to see. Vriska and Terezi were close friends during their childhood, who on Alternia formed the Scourge Sisters, Team Charge's FLARP rivals. MS Paint Adventures by Andrew Hussie. 36.87%. nothing you have written is debunking anything, it's just you saying you don't agree/see it. Theres the aforementioned not-finishing-the-story-ness I talked about earlier. But the Song of Ice and Fire series is twice as long by wordcount, and that's not even finished. There's just about one for every group. Homestuck is two or three biggish novels' worth of illustrated text, Pyscholonials isnt about Andrew Hussie and it isnt a Homestuck sequel. Snowman It wasn't even that funny! 1.4K Takers Personality Quiz. I'm on the same boat here. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, "Hussie is terrible because of recent incidents like the released emails between the moderation team and him". Reading Homestuck is no easy feat, and will take a large amount of time. Ill give credit where credit is due, and then some. And then John implies that its maybe Jakes fault for letting it get as bad as it did? what better profession is there in this world? I saw a lot of promise in Johns relationship with Roxy. and i think its mostly to do with homestucks treatment of femininity vs masculinity in a way that is not typically done The [Online Poisoned] often even joke with self awareness about their bad internet habits, but [they] just keep doing it, Hussie said. I perhaps havent heard from Jane fans because they dont really exist, but you get my point. OK, so who cares how old they were when they died? So what fills that vacuum is rampant speculation. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty is the latest product to feel the review bomb burn. So here's the deal: I've got a podcast that generally covers internet oddities. And then theres this punch-card based, bit-wise inventory system that they exploit to make whatever they want in the game. ships, god tier classpect theories, and vriska seem to be the biggest controversies. Thewhirlwindofanarticledropsyou on a plush cushion of narrative airexactlywhereyoustarted,butolder,wiser,andaround whole20 minutesshorterontime. Jake even blames himselflaterintheconversation, and John lets that slide. Take for example this moment early in the comic, with one of the four original kids, Dave: And compare is with a similar moment much later in the comic with a different character, one of the Trolls, Terezi: The music in the later combines Terezis Theme with the song from the original and the main melody from Crystalanthemums which at this point has been associated with her and her rival Vriska for some time now. It's a violent as hell culture created for a single purpose: victory. Throughout the course of Psycholonials, there are burning police stations, a revolution against the state, and a global pandemic all mediated through the eyes of a young woman whos trying to survive the fucked up world around her and while calling attention to its problems. At its peak, the comic entertained roughly 600,000 readers a day, and inspired one of the most robust cult followings of a generation fans filled convention floors with cosplays of the characters and filled online forums and websites like Tumblr full of fan art. Half of his comments are "N-NO, YOU?" In a personal sense, this story is an odd fusion of two allegories. I know there are more, I'll update this list when I remember them. The comics before Homestuck, particularly Problem Sleuth, were largely based on community inputs, and I believe certain parts of Homesutck initially were as well (this was before my time). And thats not even touching anything a part of Homestucks spin-off game, Hiveswap. Umm no. Maybe the epilogues are in part supposed to make us feel what its like to have to balance plot-driven meat with fluffy, character-driven candy and, even after years of practice, to still feel like youve come up short. We apologize for this inconvenience, & our engineers are working diligently to get this resolved ASAP. Im all for fair criticism, but this aint it. The Homestuck following was (and is in many ways still) very involved with the project. WebDreamWorks. Wait, not having a shirt on is sexual now? What Hussie describes is a dynamic that we see play out again and again online. Even worse, Hussie confirming dersecest to be a canon ship in a doomed timeline in the most recent homestuck book, which is better explained in this post. Homestuck is literature and here is why - Ableism in Homestuck Meat, like Lord English, is already here. People actually pull a bigger fit about the fact that it was retconed than they ever did over the original joke. The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. And then they play it. He has on multiple occasions, appropriated AAVE while writing her. I dont know what to say or think about any of this at this point. I still maintain that any album with a song entitled Pumpkin Party in Sea Hitlers Water Apocalypse is a good album by default on principle now and forever. I read the links, and I don't see it. A weekly roundup of the best things from Polygon, By submitting your email, you agree to our, Andrew Hussie, the reluctant cult leader, on life after Homestuck, Sign up for the I don't think people give the tumblr community enough credit for how much creative content it produces, but they are right that the SJW side can get a little over the top. In fact, you yourself just said that "Japanese highschool girl esque- outfits" are sexual. WebSnowman is the eighth member of the Felt. Whos fetish. Oh that's what you meant. The solid sales performance also lifted the food retailer's profit margins. As Dirk ascends, though, he gains full awareness of the story itself. Maybe they exist in a doomed timeline, or as a ghost, or in an offshoot reality that got retconned and is no longer relevant. The April 2019 epilogues are less a long-awaited conclusion to an epic and more the last spasms of a stream-of-consciousness-turned-webcomic that collapsed under its own weight years ago. I like my complaints like I like my inception, always going one level deeper. Damara speaks in broken english, and her japanese is straight from google translate. He needs everything to be relevant, and if a few character motivations and arcs need to get bent out of shape for that to happen, so be it. [Updated] Verizon says users unable to activate their devices due Volume 18 comes with a developer warning, showing fully that theyre aware of how fucked up this is. Article continues below advertisement. This is silly on a few levels. READER,PLAYER].DIE();: What Kind Of Elise on Twitter: "@vomitcore Wait is homestuck problematic?" / While weve seen characters manipulate time before, Lord Englishs control over all of time in all of its forms is so absolute, his presence in the narrative is already guaranteed. This is basically what I did, and these two ideas mix together in the narrative., Prior to releasing this story, Hussie struggled to pinpoint what his brand was as the creator of Homestuck. (As he puts it, its about the things its about.) The story presents a modern path to revolution in which the catalyst for the overthrow of an imperialist system is not the military strongmen of old, but a young woman with social media savvy. At the end of Candy, Calliope declares that Dirk must be stopped because unlike her, he introduces bias to the narrative. The majority of the story, other than the epilogue they are minors. It loosely correlates with my past experience of presiding over a big fandom and watching it spin out of control, using much more fantastical elements like revolution and global conquest as the backdrop. I wrote in second person. We have different media, slang, food, hobbies, etc, so Hussie's references soared straight over my head. The language used might seem lamentable to a young person today, but much of Homestuck is a product of its time. Especially assholes brazen enough to supply your own thoughts to you with a subtle perspective shift from first to second person. (I'm pretty sure this subreddit has a "CAUCASIAN" and "PEACHY" emote, but I can't remember what it is, so if anyone else remembers, could you tell me?). In a video published in April 2021, Canadian YouTuber Sarah Z delved into the history of Homestuck and Hiveswap, with a focus on the turbulent development cycle of Hiveswap. why But the comic you included in the docs is dumb and makes no sense to me. Homestuck uses Flash, which means that it has This can feel like mockery to some, and to some degree, it is but there is usually a point behind doing so. When I was a kid, my brother and I would play a game Ive come to call And Then. Hell no. WebBut, there is still no ETA for everything to work normally again. Jade was one of my favorite characters. Conspiracy theories, outright fabrications, connecting dots on whatever precious facts are known to paint whatever picture the theorizer wants to paint. There is no denying that. Id post a sample here if reading my old work didnt literally set me on fire. Yeah, we all have seen that one before. Troll Jewish would have been a great addition! WebMost toxic K-Pop fandoms include ARMY (BTS), EXO (EXOTIC), Twice (Once), and more. Copyright issues; unlike many, more mainstream content producers who kind of give convention artists alleys the big shrugaroo, Hussie, as a small buisness owner, is very strict about people selling fanmade Homestuck content. Energy transfers to keep her alive are sexual now, I guess You get assaulted by a lot of trolls. true wait, what? How the hell do people extrapolate that? Just more things: more plot, more dialogue, more mechanics, more characters, more questions, on and on and on and on until it just runs out of breath and falls over. Sure, each panel is a webpage connected by links, but almost every panel only has one link, and thats to the next panel. Dedicated fans even created a browser extension that notified you the moment new Homestuck content went up. All that being said, and the despite the two months its been since the epilogues first came out, I dont think I have an opinion on them that can be reduced to I liked them or I hated them. Kismessitudes really were just abusive relationships (we never saw a healthy example, the "dead ringer" of a black romance, Spades Slick and the troll's Black Queen, has BQ stab Slick in the eye and cut off his hand and Slick later shooters her. 1,362,830. Character development is important, but youre not a good author if your story is just 100 thousand words of characters dicking around and having repetitive conversations. How to Read Homestuck: 8 Steps (with Pictures) - wikiHow Any art of a character on a body pillow has a 90% chance of it being sexual. If I release a book full of just Nazi shit but end it by saying "BTW these aren't my views I was writing as a character lol" I can't use that to cover my ass for writing a book full of Nazi shit. In the final act of Homestuck were told the artifact defeats Lord English, and were told he dies after getting sunk in a black hole. Rose and Roxy. There exists a possibility of me being a pizza. The same can be said for any cultist.. We were weirdly concerned with fundamental narrative principles at the time, more so than little kids had any right to be. There are some aspects of Homestuck that deserve a deeper analysis and deconstruction than I can give here. The character's sue like traits and abilities get them through non important bits, but fail them when they need them most. Why The outfits Jade is wearing is her outfit she wore when she was 13, implying her age in the art. Mabye I am just dumb, but I didn't notice. I don't really care about homestuck drama, it is a product of its time as another comment said but.. OP seems vastly unaware of a lot of social issues to be "responding" to this drama. Let's go: Meenah died at 19, this iteration of Vriska died at 13. Like who? It seems that whatever small ways I was able to control that brand, back when I still was interested in doing so, has since become dramatically overwritten by the preposterous hallucinatory projections of a zealous fandom.. The Meat/Candy dichotomy is one Hussie developed for himself long before the release of the epilogues. The implosion of Silvergate Bank has a lot to do with the fact that it was crypto's bank of choice. But it's also a prime example of the hidden insolvency that exists across much of the banking sector. The lesson here is that an abuse victim needed to learn to take life into their own hands sooner. And then theres this gang war between these black alien mobsters, the Midnight Crew, and a time gang, the Felt, whos boss, Lord English is destined to destroy the multiverse. Andrew Hussie - Wikipedia The mysteries. In fact, its this difference in writing style, more than any in-story actions, that drive the main thrust of the rivalry between these two. Likewise Mindfang's joyous rape-and-murder spree of a memoir is discussed in text (And it's never graphic. This is that second one though. The game never mentions it. Calliope isnt the protagonist to Dirks antagonism, they are equal and opposite forces that corrode the narrative from different directions. 15 jan 2023 08:41:30 They should have stuck with what they said. In case you don't know what I am talking about: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ojLmFm-WUrCZ7fXALowpiAW7jklCfq14n0Zz1ECdsX0/mobilebasic, https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Z_pA2pfbnyXjxMx4PZm_LNbRSO3cZuZJ2jOOD1RpE0o/edit. Female trolls having breasts. As of now, recordings of the content exist on YouTube and are embedded where the Flash animations used to be, but take it from me when I say its really not the same. Is this. He who is without sin may cast the first stone. Ever heard of that? So to that end I'd like to know what events caused the biggest splash with fans. The fact that Andrew Hussies Homestuck is terrible is an immutable fact I am stating for the record. why you lookiing at my flaiir. And then theres genocide. I couldn't even tell he was meant to be trans. Heck, people are still debating troll genitalia). 36.87%. Anyone who presides over something popular is forced to play the role of an informal cult leader, which is what it felt like throughout most of Homestucks run, and even well beyond. He said, Some online personalities will revel in that role, and actually start behaving like a true cult leader. why homestuck is problematic God I cant stand moral guardians like that. is problematic Why Dirk, though, happens not to subscribe to Uncle Bens mantras about power and responsibility. Could things have been done differently for better effect? Even if you make the argument that karkat and vriska are technically adults now, we only saw that in the epilogue. Theres enough music that the music references itself as you move through the story, creating a kind of self-contained musical canon. The end credits and post-end credits content were released in the style of Snapchat posts. Asaresult, the narrative remains incomplete and unstable, and the relevance of key events is questioned all together. Hell, a lot of the stuff they accuse the story of, the story itself pokes fun at (such as all the accusations of pedophillia, something that Doc Scratch was openly considered creepy for in-universe) This really just feels like someone who was trying really hard to find bad things to say about the series. An otherwise slumbering fandom ignited as people filled Reddit forums with speculation. We did investigate it. Pedophilia and incest in one fell swoop. Then again, depending on the atmosphere of any given moment in fandom, there may be at least as many simps projecting absurd deification fantasises on the leader.. Hussie: lets go on this journey of discovery together. I don't agree with the original doc, but yes, OP wrote a terribly annoying post. The back half of the comic focuses on (in the most charitable definition of the word focus) the fight to stop Lord English. "The Help" became the most-watched movie on Netflix over the past week, according to their US trend bar. But I strongly recommend it! Submit fanart, cosplay and discussions of all kinds! Ardata literally has a red room esque set up, where she tortures trolls that she has caged in her hive. WebA tale about a boy and his friends and a game they play together. Im not sure how much there is thats truly positive about those things, but there is plenty which is negative. The impressive thing is, these couldve easily just been throw-away, cheap, forced, gags. I just had no idea until you told me just now. Wi-Fi 6E is the latest Wi-Fi technology that provides faster speeds, lower latency, and improved overall network performance. There. People generally overlook when boys are sexualized, (examples, all the shirtless art of the boys of BNHA, the entire Free series, etc.). Debunking the "Hussie is terrible" Google Docs link : r/homestuck Theres even a page that compels the reader to take selfies and post them on social media. From troll call, right? WebWhy Homestucks Disaster of an Epilogue was so Bad 9,982 views Jul 7, 2019 330 Dislike Share Skooter 58 subscribers Omg I started this April this took me like 3 and a half months sksksskks. She is secure in who she is, complete with her disability, without the desire to be fixed or normal. Despite this small, impressive moment, Homestuck is, overall, extremely ableist and disrespectful toward its disabled characters, and real persons with disabilities. I will just go ahead and read through the Google Docs about Hussie being terrible and comment every time I have something to say. The result is probably one of the coolest pages in the whole comic, and one of the coolest things Ive seen done in fiction changing nothing but the size and color of the text. If you are talking about, Karkat: hey asshole, stop playing games for girls, then I see it differently from you. But it's also a prime example of the hidden insolvency that exists across much of the banking sector. Homestucks saturation of timeline and narrative chicanery means that there are always multiple versions of each character that exist somewhere in the story, probably even at the same time.